Eric Nicholas K's answer to Candice lim's Secondary 4 A Maths Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K's answer
5997 answers (Tutor Details)
1st
Candice, we have to prove that dy/dx cannot equal zero (because the gradient of the line y = 3.5 is zero).

There are two cases to consider here; if h + k = 0, the curve does not even exist; in all other cases, we cannot make dy/dx zero since we cannot equate the denominator to zero in attempting to obtain a zero gradient.
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
6 years ago
Missed out the “1/2” in my final expression for dy/dx
J
J
6 years ago
Candice, a point to take note :

It is actually possible for the denominator of dy/dx to become 0.

That is when x = -h. Which means

y = √((-h+h)/(k-x)
y = √0/(k-x)
= √0
= 0

This means that for the point (-h,0), the slope or gradient ( i.e dy/dx) is undefined since the denominator of dy/dx = 0


If k = x, then y would be undefined since :

y = √(h+x)/(k-k)
y = √((h+x)/0)

The denominator is 0 here. So there is no point on the curve where x = k.

And, when x = k, the denominator of dy/dx also is 0, which means the gradient is undefined.

(Which is quite obvious, since there cannot be any gradient , when the point is not even defined in the first place.)

This also reminds us that x = k is a vertical asymptote of the curve.
Candice lim
Candice Lim
6 years ago
Thank you so much, Mr Eric. I really appreciate your help to provide me with the working solution :)

Thanks again !
Candice lim
Candice Lim
6 years ago
yes Mr Eric, I do notice the missing "1/2" :)
I've added it myself into the working solution provided by you. Thanks for highlighting.
Candice lim
Candice Lim
6 years ago
Noted your point, Mr J. Thanks.
J
J
6 years ago
I actually left an explanation in the main comments section way earlier before this post was even up. His working is similar to mine. Hope you saw it
Candice lim
Candice Lim
6 years ago
yes Mr J. Almost missed out the earlier comments by both you and Mr Eric. So sorry...my apologies.

I have just managed to digest it :) Thank you so much for taking time to provide me with the explanation.