Woon Kiat's answer to Yeo's Primary 6 Science Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Woon Kiat
Woon Kiat's answer
322 answers (Tutor Details)
1st
Hope it helps.

Elastic spring force generally opposes gravitational force. So if subjected to the same amount of gravitational force, the one which can resist that force (stiffer) has greater spring force.
Yeo
Yeo
4 years ago
HI, thanks for explaining.
But the solution in this paper was spring y has lesser length of compression when sane load of mass is placed on. Hence, there will be more elastic PE in Spring Y than Spring X when compressed to the same length that is converted to KE of the metal disc which is transferred to KE of the candy.

Why must the student explain in term of elastic PE energy and not elastic Spring force?
Woon Kiat
Woon Kiat
4 years ago
In the context of the candy dispenser, both springs will be compressed to the same degree. As such, spring Y which has a greater spring force will store a greater amount of elastic PE than X. As a result, the candy will have more kinetic energy (elastic PE converted to KE) thus moving faster.

So the elastic PE is more relevant than the elastic spring force.
Woon Kiat
Woon Kiat
4 years ago
The elastic PE is a composite measurement which include both the elastic spring force and the degree of ccompression. So force alone is insufficient to explain the faster movement in most cases.