Teo Jer Rei's answer to Ashley ong 's Primary 6 Maths Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Teo Jer Rei
Teo Jer Rei's answer
12 answers (A Helpful Person)
Yes, the student made a careless mistake in line 5 and 6 of his/her original working. The student went to find the total number of carnations/roses the florist had, instead of the number of carnations/roses the florist sold. (take note that the florist did not sell all her roses and carnations).

I've written the corrected solutions, and learning points below. I hope this helps :)
Ashley ong
Ashley Ong
3 years ago
So there is no error in the qn?
Ashley ong
Ashley Ong
3 years ago
The roses should be more than carnation right? But the answer shows that the opposite.
Ashley ong
Ashley Ong
3 years ago
So total of roses is 560 and carnation is 700? But roses is 140 more than carnation. Sorry..need to convince my girl..
Teo Jer Rei
Teo Jer Rei
3 years ago
Oh wait I’m so sorry I read the question wrongly also!!
Question has an error. It should be “140 LESS roses than carnations”
Teo Jer Rei
Teo Jer Rei
3 years ago
I’m sorry for the confusion...I made a careless mistake also and read the question wrongly.

Roses has 4 units, carnations has 5 units. It is thus impossible for roses to be MORE than carnations, should be “less than”. Your daughter is right.
Teo Jer Rei
Teo Jer Rei
3 years ago
The attached picture of the working will only be correct if the question is:

“There are 140 more carnations than roses”.
Ashley ong
Ashley Ong
3 years ago
Thanks much for your clarification!!