Rachael's answer to Mandy's Primary 6 Maths Fractions Singapore question.
done
{{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear
{{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Hope this helps!
Date Posted:
4 years ago
May i know how u get 1840? Next 3 units should be 92 x 3 = 276...when u mention 20 units = 1840 divide by 20 units in order to find 1 unit.
I obtained a different answer of $270 at the end as explained in the question’s comments section.
In summary, I got these:
Before
Box A: 400 pieces 50c, 180 pieces $1
Box B: 160 pieces 50c, 1100 pieces $1
Transfer made is 380 pieces 50c, 160 pieces $1
After
Box A: 20 pieces 50c, 20 pieces $1 (so percentage of 50c is 50%)
Box B: 540 pieces 50c, 1260 pieces $1 (so percentage of 50c is 30%)
For a total value of $270 worth of 50c coins in Box B.
In summary, I got these:
Before
Box A: 400 pieces 50c, 180 pieces $1
Box B: 160 pieces 50c, 1100 pieces $1
Transfer made is 380 pieces 50c, 160 pieces $1
After
Box A: 20 pieces 50c, 20 pieces $1 (so percentage of 50c is 50%)
Box B: 540 pieces 50c, 1260 pieces $1 (so percentage of 50c is 30%)
For a total value of $270 worth of 50c coins in Box B.
This is just my line of thought and may not represent a correct solution or working.
Rachael, Box B started out with
160 pieces of 50c coins
at first, so there could not have been
92 pieces of 50c coins
in Box B at the end, considering that coins are being transferred from Box A to Box B but no coins are being transferred from Box B to Box A.
Edit: Had not seen your updated comments of 276 coins in time.
160 pieces of 50c coins
at first, so there could not have been
92 pieces of 50c coins
in Box B at the end, considering that coins are being transferred from Box A to Box B but no coins are being transferred from Box B to Box A.
Edit: Had not seen your updated comments of 276 coins in time.
One flaw I spotted in Rachael’s working is that the “1/2” and “3/10” cannot be actually added together, since we are not actually dealing with the same number of coins in both boxes.
The fractions 1/2 and 3/10 in “1/2 of 100 coins and 3/10 of 100 coins” can be added
but
the fractions 1/2 and 3/10 in “1/2 of 100 coins and 3/10 of 500 coins” cannot be added.
The fractions 1/2 and 3/10 in “1/2 of 100 coins and 3/10 of 100 coins” can be added
but
the fractions 1/2 and 3/10 in “1/2 of 100 coins and 3/10 of 500 coins” cannot be added.
I decided to give Rachael an upvote for the effort that she has put in, although there is a slight inaccuracy in the concept of the working.
That's cool. Mandy remember to thank your tutors Rachael and Eric too! Happy learning. :)