Eric Nicholas K's answer to .'s Secondary 3 A Maths Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K's answer
5997 answers (Tutor Details)
1st
I might be wrong this time
J
J
5 years ago
On your left hand side of the equation , it should be 9p² + 9 instead of 9p² + 9p
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
5 years ago
Still, I doubt that a student newly at the Sec 3 level would be able to notice it whilst attempting this chapter.

Furthermore, it’s not that often that students at the Sec 3 level obtain a solution which is “always possible for all real values of an unknown”.

This is because when they face questions, their answers are usually expressed in a restricted inequality form. Their expectations of such solutions make them unsure that this would be possible as a solution.
J
J
5 years ago
See the updated comment
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
5 years ago
Right, I update this later
J
J
5 years ago
Anyway, your last paragraph is actually the very defining factor that differentiates the best students from the rest. Conceptual testing.
J
J
5 years ago
Nowadays, the questions in the textbook tend towards more deep thinking and conceptual understanding and analysis rather than the rote application of formulas and methods. It's a good move though.
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
5 years ago
Ashley, I have updated this on the main chat text
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
5 years ago
I think that when students are presented with such possibilities for the first time, they might be unaccepting of it and might have the lack of confidence to accept the answer as true
J
J
5 years ago
Usually the first thing to do is to check for errors in working and logic.

If there is no error at all, then it only logically leads to the derived result being true.