Arnold K H Tan's answer to Candice lim's Secondary 4 A Maths Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Arnold K H Tan
Arnold K H Tan's answer
2108 answers (A Helpful Person)
1st
Always try to simplify the expression before differentiation - Grandmaster Eric's sidekick.
Candice lim
Candice Lim
3 years ago
Thanks for the advice, Mr Tan.
I got the same answer but it wasn't the right answer (I am assuming that the model answer given is correct).
Arnold K H Tan
Arnold K H Tan
3 years ago
It does happen that model answers are incorrect. Or there was a mistake made during the proofreading and editing of the question. Post the answer - one can often work backwards to elucidate the intended question.
Candice lim
Candice Lim
3 years ago
Hi Mr Tan, the model answer is Pi e^-a/3 (b-1).
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
3 years ago
Candice, I tried plotting the graph of f(x) on Desmos as well but obtained the expected - a horizontal line.
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
3 years ago
Candice, the model answer looks fishy. The derivative of e^f(x) always contains some expression containing x within the power, the most basic of which is e^x which is invariant after differentiation.

I tried eliminating the "b" in the denominator, but obtained another expression

f(x) = π times e^(-a/3) times e^[(b - 1) x]

which differentiates to the same expression as above, multiplied by a factor (b - 1).

In this case, the e^[(b - 1) x] remains present. Or put it simply, even the letter "x" should survive, but the model answer seems to miss out the letter "x".
Candice lim
Candice Lim
3 years ago
Hi Mr Tan, with both Mr Eric and Mr Chau's advice. I strongly believe that the model answer given to me is incorrect. You are right :)

Thank you for your feedback and have a good day ahead.