Zhe Xun's answer to Vignesh anand's Secondary 4 A Maths Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Zhe Xun
Zhe Xun's answer
113 answers (Tutor Details)
1st
I think you missed one answer because you cancelled out x in your earlier workings
Vignesh anand
Vignesh Anand
5 years ago
I cancelled it. No wonder I didnt get the other ans. Thanks a lot
Vignesh anand
Vignesh Anand
5 years ago
Just wondering, since x sq is 8. So x is +/_ sq root 8. We dont use - sq root 8?
Zhe Xun
Zhe Xun
5 years ago
You can, there are actually 3 points of intersections, just that the gradient is the same for x=root8 and -root8
Vignesh anand
Vignesh Anand
5 years ago
Right. Both gave -7
Eric Nicholas K
Eric Nicholas K
5 years ago
The "1 = sqrt (9 - x²)" is not exactly "wrong", although I know what you are trying to mean.

Also possible, if the student is aware of single x appearing on both sides, is

x = x sqrt (9 - x²)

x = 0 or 1 = sqrt (9 - x²)

As long as the "x = 0" appears in the next line, the student has correctly identified a solution.
Zhe Xun
Zhe Xun
5 years ago
Thanks for clarifying :)