AC Lim's answer to Kc's Primary 5 Maths Area & Volume Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
AC Lim
Ac Lim's answer
13094 answers (A Helpful Person)
1st
Actually triangle with dimensions 5cm, 12 cm and 13 cm is right angle triangle. .. but primary level haven’t teach. Hope this helps
J
J
5 years ago
This diagram is mathematically incorrect as the unshaded triangle is supposed be right angled as well, but its dimensions don't satisfy the Pythagoras' theorem since 15² + 12² = 369 ≠ 20²
snell
Snell
5 years ago
still make use of info that angle ADC is right angle
J
J
5 years ago
To be fair to a P5 student, the value of angle BDC and ADC aren't even given. Amd neither are stated as right angles.

Hence my earlier comment that it has to be assumed that BDC is right angled (which then would imply that ADC is right angled since AB is taken to be a straight line), since they're not expected to infer that the shaded triangle satisfies Pythagoras' Theorem and thus conclude BDC is 90°.

Or, assume that ADC is right angled.
AC Lim
AC Lim
5 years ago
How about use AD : BD = 3:1... are we able to find area for ABC... ?
J
J
5 years ago
Will still get 120 cm² for ABC
AC Lim
AC Lim
5 years ago
Meaning we still need to assume ADC is a right angle.Really mathematically error question;(
J
J
5 years ago
Yup. The teacher/set probably expects assumption to be done. Otherwise it could be that they forgot to mark either as a right angle.
J
J
5 years ago
If we let AC = AB be x instead,

Then x² = 12² + (x - 5)²

x² = 144 + x² - 10x + 25

10x = 169
x = 16.9

So what the teacher/setter should have done is let AB = AC = 16.9 cm