J's answer to Anonymous's Secondary 3 A Maths Singapore question.
done
{{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear
{{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
Short way :
(n r) = (n (n- r))
For example, (10 7) = (10 (10-7)) = (10 3)
So if (n 5) = (n 3), and (n 5) = (n (n - 5)),
Then 3 = n - 5
n = 3 + 5 = 8
Long way : refer to comment section.
(n r) = (n (n- r))
For example, (10 7) = (10 (10-7)) = (10 3)
So if (n 5) = (n 3), and (n 5) = (n (n - 5)),
Then 3 = n - 5
n = 3 + 5 = 8
Long way : refer to comment section.
Date Posted:
5 years ago
Long way : Use the formula definition for (n r)
(n r) = n! / r!(n - r)!
(n 5) = (n 3)
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
Cross multiply,
n! 3! (n - 3)! = n! 5! (n - 5)!
n! 3! (n - 3) (n - 4) (n - 5)! = n! (5)(4) 3! (n - 5)!
n! 3! (n - 3) (n - 4) (n - 5)! - 20 n! 3! (n - 5)! = 0
n! 3! (n - 5)! ( (n - 3)(n - 4) - 20 ) = 0
Since the factorials are non-zero, then
(n - 3)(n - 4) - 20 = 0
n² - 4n - 3n + 12 - 20 = 0
n² - 7n - 8 = 0
(n + 1)(n - 8) = 0
n + 1 = 0 or n - 8 = 0
n = -1 (rejected as n > 5)
or n = 8
(n r) = n! / r!(n - r)!
(n 5) = (n 3)
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
Cross multiply,
n! 3! (n - 3)! = n! 5! (n - 5)!
n! 3! (n - 3) (n - 4) (n - 5)! = n! (5)(4) 3! (n - 5)!
n! 3! (n - 3) (n - 4) (n - 5)! - 20 n! 3! (n - 5)! = 0
n! 3! (n - 5)! ( (n - 3)(n - 4) - 20 ) = 0
Since the factorials are non-zero, then
(n - 3)(n - 4) - 20 = 0
n² - 4n - 3n + 12 - 20 = 0
n² - 7n - 8 = 0
(n + 1)(n - 8) = 0
n + 1 = 0 or n - 8 = 0
n = -1 (rejected as n > 5)
or n = 8
Alternatively,
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
Divide both sides by n!
(We can do so since n! is non-zero)
1 / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!(n - 3)!
Multiply both sides by (n - 3)!
(We can do so for the same reason as above, since n > 5 implies n - 3 > 2, so (n - 3)! is also non zero
(n - 3)! / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!
(n - 3)(n - 4)(n - 5)! / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!
(n - 3)(n - 4) / 5! = 1 / 3!
Multiply both sides by 5!
(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5! / 3!
n² - 4n - 3n + 12 = 5 × 4 × 3! / 3!
n² - 7n + 12 = 20
n² - 7n - 8 = 0
(n + 1)(n - 8) = 0
n = -1(reject as n > 5) or n = 8
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
Divide both sides by n!
(We can do so since n! is non-zero)
1 / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!(n - 3)!
Multiply both sides by (n - 3)!
(We can do so for the same reason as above, since n > 5 implies n - 3 > 2, so (n - 3)! is also non zero
(n - 3)! / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!
(n - 3)(n - 4)(n - 5)! / 5!(n - 5)! = 1 / 3!
(n - 3)(n - 4) / 5! = 1 / 3!
Multiply both sides by 5!
(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5! / 3!
n² - 4n - 3n + 12 = 5 × 4 × 3! / 3!
n² - 7n + 12 = 20
n² - 7n - 8 = 0
(n + 1)(n - 8) = 0
n = -1(reject as n > 5) or n = 8
Second alternative
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(2)(1) / 5!(n - 5)(n - 4)...(2)(1) = n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(2)(1) / 3!(n - 3)(n - 2)...(2)(1)
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) / 5! = n(n - 1)(n - 2) / 3!
(This result shows us that n! / r!(n - r)! = n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(n - r + 1) / r!
The right hand side is the equivalent expression for (n r) )
Multiply both sides by 5!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5!n(n - 1)(n - 2)/3!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5(4)(3!)n(n - 1)(n - 2)/3!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 20n(n - 1)(n - 2)
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) - 20n(n - 1)(n - 2) = 0
n(n - 1)(n - 2)((n - 3)(n - 4) - 20) = 0
Since n > 5 implies n, n - 1, n - 2 > 0, these terms are non zero terms.
So ((n - 3)(n - 4) - 20) must = 0 in order to be equal to the right hand side.
Solving for this gives you the same result as the other methods.
n! / 5!(n - 5)! = n! / 3!(n - 3)!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(2)(1) / 5!(n - 5)(n - 4)...(2)(1) = n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(2)(1) / 3!(n - 3)(n - 2)...(2)(1)
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) / 5! = n(n - 1)(n - 2) / 3!
(This result shows us that n! / r!(n - r)! = n(n - 1)(n - 2)...(n - r + 1) / r!
The right hand side is the equivalent expression for (n r) )
Multiply both sides by 5!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5!n(n - 1)(n - 2)/3!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 5(4)(3!)n(n - 1)(n - 2)/3!
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) = 20n(n - 1)(n - 2)
n(n - 1)(n - 2)(n - 3)(n - 4) - 20n(n - 1)(n - 2) = 0
n(n - 1)(n - 2)((n - 3)(n - 4) - 20) = 0
Since n > 5 implies n, n - 1, n - 2 > 0, these terms are non zero terms.
So ((n - 3)(n - 4) - 20) must = 0 in order to be equal to the right hand side.
Solving for this gives you the same result as the other methods.