J's answer to Jovi's Primary 5 Maths Area & Volume Singapore question.

done {{ upvoteCount }} Upvotes
clear {{ downvoteCount * -1 }} Downvotes
J
J's answer
1024 answers (A Helpful Person)
$0.80 for each intact plate.
$0.80 × 5 = $4.00
For every 5 plates delivered intact, the company charges him $4.00. But this will be offset by 1 broken plate's penalty of $4.00. The charge is offset/negated by the penalty.
So we group every 5 intact plates and 1 broken plate into 1 set.
5 + 1 = 6 so there are 6 plates in each set.
There are a total of 500 plates to be delivered.
500 ÷ 6 = 83 R2
We can have 83 such sets with 2 leftover. So for 83 sets, there are 83 plates that can be broken. (83 sets × 1 broken plate per set)
The 2 leftover plates must be intact because :
①If 1 was intact and the other broken, the company charges $0.80 for the intact one but pays $4.00 for the broken one. Overall the company has to pay $4.00 - $0.80 = $3.20
②If both are broken the company pays $4.00 × 2 = $8.00
So maximum number of plates that can be broken = 83
J
J
3 years ago
Assumption method :

① Assume 80 broken plates, 420 intact ones

Penalty = 80 × $4 = $320
Charged amount = 420 × $0.80 = $336

Overall amount earned = $336 - $320 = $16


② Replace one intact plate with a broken plate.

Increase in penalty = $4
Decrease in charged amount = $0.80

Overall decease in amount earned = $4 + $0.80 = $4.80

Replace one plate : $16 - $4.80 = $11.20
Replace a second plate : $11.20 - $4.80 = $6.40
Replace a third plate : 6.40 - $4.80 = $1.60

We can replace 3 intact plates at most.

If we replace another, that would be decreasing by another $4.80.

Instead of earning $1.60 ,

$4.80 - $1.60 = $2.40

The company has to pay a penalty of $2.40 now.


So max number of plates = 80 + 3 = 83